THE WEEKLY
REFLEKTION
-
The Weekly Reflektion 52/2022
Labour shortages led to the bridge crew of the Helge Ingstad being less experienced than was the norm, but the job had not got any easier. Were the bridge crew on Helge Ingstad negligent, or did the Norwegian Navy set them up to fail? This is the second Reflektion focussed on the incident on 8th November […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 51/2022
The Helge Ingstad sinking involved three parties, the Helge Ingstad itself, the tanker Sola TS, and the local marine vessel traffic service. The incident illustrates some of the challenges associated with people, the way people communicate and the assumptions they have when they are trying to make sense of the world around them. People in […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 50/2022
The investigations into major accidents often note the signals before the accident that indicated some things were not right. The disregard for safety precautions, the breaches of the control of work procedure, recurring incidents, concerns from the staff. Sometimes the signals are strong, for example a dropped object from 20 meters. Sometimes the information may […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 49/2022
When we are thinking about our Reflektions and especially what to write about next week, we are seldom short on material on accidents and incidents. There are unfortunately many ‘good’ examples of Major Accidents that we can use. The challenge is to find the right context and ensure there are relevant points that our readers […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 48/2022
The investigation into major accidents usually leads to recommendations on improvements in safety. While we may not be aware of all of these, we have an expectation that they will be implemented. How do you align your objectives in your ‘One Team’ concept? The Los Rodeos Airport in Tenerife airport suffered with poor visibility when low clouds. On 27th March […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 47/2022
Drilling wells and carrying out projects are examples of activities that involve personnel from different companies working together to complete the required tasks safely and effectively. However, these companies may not have the same individual commercial goals and sometimes these differencescan lead to poor performance and a disappointing result, at least for some of the participants. In the petroleum industry an example […]
read more
To sign up for our Weekly Reflektion Newsletter, fill in your information.
Please check your SPAM mail if you do not receive your confirmation e-mail.
-
The Weekly Reflektion 46/2022
Our days are full of alternatives and choices, and we need to decide which of these to follow. In our workplace we also make decisions and sometimes these can have significant consequences. We need to have a process that considers all the relevant information, the potential hazards, the uncertainties, and the consequences, before a decision […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 45/2022
Language and communication have been major factors in the evolution of humans. The ability to learn and adapt to changing environments gave homo sapiens a great advantage despite obvious deficiencies in strength and speed compared with other predators and prey. Before the advent of writing systems communication was verbal, and it is likely that the […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 44/2022
Automatic safety systems fulfil an important function in the prevention of unsafe conditions and the escalation of any incident. Failure to register and react to alarms and overriding key safety functions can compromise this function and make any facility vulnerable to a Major Accident. It seems obvious that alarm handling and control of overrides should […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 43/2022
The current energy crisis in Europe demonstrates how important power is to industrial and domestic users and to maintain the services society requires. Like many aspects of life, we only really appreciate them when we are close to losing them. We cannot afford to be complacent on essential services. The Viking Sky cruise ship nearly […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 42/2022
During wartime and busy periods rules and regulations are often relaxed to ‘get the job done’. How do we ensure we focus on the right things when the context of our operations change? On 6th December 1917, during the First World War, two ships collided, causing an explosion which killed at least 1782 people and demolished […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 41/2022
Risk assessments are used extensively in decision making and it is important one understands the dynamics taking place in the assessment process. Obviously, we would expect the participants in the risk assessment process to be objective, the data accurate and the analysis of the data thorough and unambiguous. In the real work this may not […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 40/2022
Risk assessments are a key part of ensuring that any activity or project can be carried out safely. Risk assessments can be major activities with multiple participants perhaps over several days. Risk assessments can also be short and sweet and consist of a quick review before the job gets done. What are the factors that influence whether […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 39/2022
Using solutions that others have used before you does not necessarily mean that it will work for you. Sometimes the circumstances are not quite the same, or maybe the others were just lucky and got away with it. Resultant derailment and diagram showing situation immediately before collision (Source: BNSF) Do you have contingencies prepared if the activity doesn’t go to plan? On November 13, 2021, about 2343 hrs, a freight train consisting of […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 38/2022
One of the main concerns raised at risk assessments associated with lifetime extension of facilities is assurance of competence and capacity in the organisation until the facilities are decommissioned. People in the organisation often recognize the technical challenges and feel they have the necessary control to ensure prudent operations at the current time. They are […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 37/2022
Acronyms are abbreviations formed from the initial letters of the words in the expression being abbreviated. Some acronyms become so well established that they replace the original name or expression, e.g., NASA, IOU, SNAFU. Often the acronym becomes memorable and conveys a distinct understanding. The acronyms we are using today are WYLFIWYF and WYFIWYF. Are you aware that the mandate for an investigation and […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 36/2022
Having people that are competent to carry out their work and exercise their responsibilities is of course essential. Just as essential is ensuring that there are enough people with the full range of competencies needed for the work to be undertaken. The Tretten bridge after it collapsed Do you have the competence to ensure your […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 35/2022
People doing safety critical work should have sufficient restbefore work. Regulatory requirements and company policiesshould be put in place to ensure this. Seaway Falcon pumping sea water on to Ekofisk Bravo platform during the blowout. ©NTB How do you ensure cost saving measures do not reduce the safety level? In April 1977, an oil well blowout occurred at the Ekofisk Bravo platform. The direct cause of […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 34/2022
When a design weakness has been identified, compensating measures have to be agreed and implemented. The tail elevators showing the right one locked down in the wrong position for take off Are your compensating measures adequate? Thanks to Neil Sultan, one of our subscribers for bringing this incident to our attention. On 8th March 2017, an MD83 aircraft, a variant of the DC-9 from Boeing McDonnell […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 33/2022
An organisation continually receives information that is relevant to its operation and that can be used to make improvements. This of course requires a proper interpretation of that information and avoidance of unsubstantiated assumptions. Pic.1 A steel helmet used by British soldiers in WW I. Pic.2 Distribution of bullet holes on allied aircraft How do you use available information […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 32/2022
A management system describes the processes and procedures that should be followed to carry out all activities in a safe and effective manner. The management system should include a learning process that ensures that these processes and procedures are continually reviewed and updated from experience in their application and changes in regulations and standards. Gas in the sea surrounding the Snorre A […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 31/2022
The culture of a company is set by the management and what the management decides to focus on and not to focus on. When the company is involved in the manufacturer of aircraft or any other activity that can lead to Major Accidents, safetyshould of course be a management focus, some may say the primary […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 30/2022
In last week’s Reflektion, week 29 -2022, we talked about how economic pressure and competition with Airbus led to the modification of the Boeing 737 MAX and the tragic consequences of two air crashes and 346 people dead. This week we will look at how the modification caused the crashes. Next week we will try […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 29/2022
The aircraft industry is highly competitive and a key factor for commercial airlines is fuel efficiency. Reducing operating costs will lead to lower fares and more customers. The customers also expect that safety standards will not be compromised in the drive to cut costs. Are you able to maintain and improve your safety standards through periods of turbulence and […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 28/2022
Convicting a criminal of a crime is the goal of police investigations. During the investigation the evidence has to be looked at objectively. This is not always the case as the police, being human, are influenced by many factors and biases. Justice is not always done. How do you avoid confirmation bias in your investigations? Marius Kolstad, a former Norwegian bodybuilding champion, was […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 27/2022
The investigation of any incident is influenced by our biases. When we know the outcome, this can affect the way we approach the investigation. In some cases, we are not even aware that we have had an incident, until the events are seen through another perspective. Do you let your biases influence your judgement? Sidney […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 26/2022
The Petroleum Safety Authority (PSA) main issue for 2022 is ‘Capacity and Competence – the key to safety’. PSA emphasizes the importance of an organization possessing the right capacity and competence. However, possessing is not enough. Your competence must be utilized properly to ensure you fulfill your responsibilities. Are you fulfilling your ‘see to it’ duty? The Norwegian petroleum industry has undergone significant […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 25/2022
Making the effort to tell others about the incidents that you have had may prevent similar incidents in other companies. While there is no guarantee that anyone else will learn from your incident you can certainly guarantee that they will notlearn if they know nothing about it. Do you make the effort to tell others about your incidents? The […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 24/2022
We often hear people claiming that the only thing that doesn’t change in their organization is continuous change. The drive for better performance, whether improving safety, reducing the effect on the environment, increasing production, reducing costs, etc, inevitably leads to a change. However, we are not always so good at understanding why something is in place before we […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 23/2022
Walking the talk is an expression that is often used to emphasize the importance of management living up to what they say. ‘Actions speak louder than words’, is used in the same context. Putting out the last of the fires at the Texas City Refinery in 2005 What does walking the talk mean in your company? We would […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 22/2022
Continuous improvement is an important factor in ensuring safe and efficient operations and pre-supposes learning and a learning process. However, not all cultures are so receptive to innovation and new thinking to benefit from learning. Do you have a culture that encourages learning or discourages learning? We would like to invite you to a ‘Listen and Reflekt’ lunchtime […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 21/2022
A simple ‘human error’ can lead to fatal consequences. Sometimes a simple solution could have prevented the human making that error and the pain and misery of lost loved ones could have been avoided. Do you design your systems to prevent the inevitable mistakes that people will eventually make? We would like to invite you to […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 20/2022
Building a culture needs actions that demonstrate that you are serious, stories to communicate these actions, and engagement to follow up that the actions have the desired effect. Do your systems and procedures apply to everyone and in every circumstance? Now that COVID is over, Mike and I would like to re-establish our Reflekt seminars to […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 19/2022
Repeated incidents show that we are often not effective at learning lessons and preventing recurrence. People can be seriously injured or die from this failure. Learning lessons demands organisational stamina to follow the process to the end. How is the stamina in your organisation? Several of our Reflektions recently have addressed the quality of investigations […]
read more -
REFLEKT LISTEN AND REFLEKT
TEAMS MEETING WEDNESDAY 1st JUNE 2022, 1100, hrs Now that COVID is over, Mike and I would like to reestablish our Reflekt seminars to promote issues that we believe could lead to improvements in the petroleum industry in Norway. We have previously held breakfast seminars at the Auditorium at Ipark, Ullandhaug and we intend to continue with these following the summer. We have […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 18/2022
Some of the routines that are carried out on a process facility may seem banal and a waste of time. They are often established as the result of a serious incident or the potential for a serious incident. Sometimes the reason is lost in time and the routine then becomes the target for the latest efficiency drive. Interlock system […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 17/2022
Failure of leadership and supervision is often noted as a factor in incidents and accidents. Unfortunately, this is often an observation made by the investigation team and not a cause that has been identified through an assessment of why the leadership/supervision failed. Are your expectations to operational leaders/supervisors clear? One of the perceived advantages of the […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 16/2022
To be able to learn from poor performance, the causes have to be identified. To be able to learn from good performance, the same is true. Martin Linge platform (©Equinor) Is learning from repeated failures in field development projects in Norway all words and little action? Last week’s Reflektion addressed the Martin Linge development in Norway and […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 15/2022
Often the successful outcome of a project or activity has little to do with the care and attention you put into the planning and execution and more to do with luck. Are you lucky, and if so, why are you lucky? A quote that is often attributed to Napoleon Bonaparte is ‘I know he’s a good general […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 14/2022
Many companies promote values that they hope the employees, and the management, will aspire to. These values are sometimes open to interpretation. Do your values encourage the right behaviours in the right circumstances? Sometimes the management gets the idea for promoting ‘values’ within the company. This process often takes place when a major reorganisation or […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 13/2022
Human error plays a part in most accidents. Do your investigations stop there? Injury to boy’s neck after accident on the ski lift. Photo: Private Do you consider ‘inherently safer design’ in your investigations? In February this year, an 11-year-old boy was on downhill skis for the first time at a Norwegian ski resort, when […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 12/2022
The quality of a Quality Assurance system is only as good as the people responsible for it. When a company loses focus on the quality of processes in place and work carried out then an accident is just waiting to happen. Aircraft ZS-OEZ, type Boeing B737-200, with starboard engine missing How do you ensure your Quality Assurance […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 11/2022
‘I get it’ said Boris Johnson as he responded to the criticism over the Downing Street Parties in January 2022. ‘BP gets it’ said then Chief Executive following the BP Texas City Refinery disaster in March 2005. In April 2010 there was the blow out on the BP Macondo well. After the parties Boris said ‘I […]
read more -
The Heimdal Incident
Failure to carry out a proper investigation of any incident, especially a serious incident, is a barrier to the learning from the incident. When reading some investigation reports and presentations, it is not surprising that learning from incidentsis a still a challenge. When you carry out investigations, do you really get to the bottom of what happened, how it happened, and why […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 10/2022
Introduction of foreign objects to a workplace may be acceptable, but this may cause unidentified hazards. RAF A330 Voyager Aircraft Do you have discipline around your work sites, and what is allowed? On 9th February 2014 an RAF Airbus A330 Voyager aircraft was flying over the Black Sea towards Afghanistan with 198 passengers and crew. The aircraft suddenly, without warning,pitched […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 09/2022
A good risk assessment requires a comprehensive overview of the actual and potential hazards and threats, and scenarios on how these will manifest themselves. This means using the imagination. The port engine of the Boeing 737 Southwest Airlines Flight 1380 Do you encourage the participants in risk assessment to use their imaginations? Risk assessments are an important tool for ensuring the safe […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 08/2022
We are all influenced by feedback. Good feedback may give us a lift and perhaps encourage us to continue what we are doing and perhaps improve. Bad feedback may get us down but could give us that kick we need to improve. What about no feedback? Well, this may just indicate you don’t care. Albert Einstein in a reflektive mood What behaviours do you encourage by […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 07/2022
The drive for effective operations must be balanced with the drilling of robust wells. Welding on a pipeline What does ‘good’ look like to you in your operations, and is it the ‘good’ expected by others? We all strive to improve performance, to do better than we have done before, to set records both for professional pride and […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 06/2022
We may trust the systems and equipment that we use to ensure that the activities we carry out are safe but not everyone is in a position to be able to trust these systems. Welding on a pipeline Are you too easily satisfied that the safety systems on your facility are functioning satisfactorily? Peter Sandman, a […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 05/2022
Even the most advanced technology with sophisticated computer programs to control its use still has the human element. The burnt our wreck of a B2 stealth bomber How do you incorporate informal procedures into your management system? The B-2 stealth bomber ‘Spirit of Kansas’ crashed on take-off at the Andersen Air Force base on Guam […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 04/2022
Sometimes we need a reminder of the importance of our quest to prevent Major Accidents. What better example than how a Major Accident can significantly affect peoples’ lives. Fire on the Deepwater Horizon April 2010 Do you practice mindful leadership in your organisation? Thank you to Mike Smith in Lotos for bringing an article in […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 03/2022
Research and Development can lead to new understanding that can change the way safety systems are designed and operated. One example is the release of water deluge in the event of a gas leak. Do you systemically review the way you carry out tasks to ensure the hazards are controlled and the risks managed? On […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 02/2022
Agreeing with the majority in a group task is the easiest solution. The task in the Asch experiment How do you ensure conformity in a group does not lead to poor decisions? In 1951, Solomon Asch, a pioneer in social psychology, performed an experiment to investigate how the effect of social pressure from a majority […]
read more -
The Weekly Reflektion 01/2022
Research and Development can lead to new understanding that can change the way safety systems are designed and operated. One example is the release of water deluge in the event of agas leak. Deluge Release on Process Facility How do you keep yourself updated with research and development related to the safety of your facilities? In the […]
read more